"There is ample private money for sound housing projects; and the Congress…can stimulate the lending of money."

Franklin D. Roosevelt, Message to Congress, June 8, 1934

When Franklin Roosevelt became President in 1933, he recognized that putting construction workers back to work would be crucial to revive the US economy. But the collapse of banks had choked off home lending. So, the following year he worked with Congress to create the Federal Housing Administration, the first of a series of actions that built the modern mortgage market as a partnership between government and banks. Today two-thirds of Americans own their own home, financed by ~$15 trillion in outstanding home loans.

Roosevelt figured out how government could harness private capital to address a major national challenge.

How can policymakers apply that same approach today?

The Challenge

Solving many of our most pressing national challenges will require harnessing private investment capital. American capital markets have the money. But it too often does not flow to where it could be used to scale up solutions.

Many of the investment tools Americans now treat as permanent, natural features of the economy — the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage, the $500 billion farm credit system, the domestic venture capital industry — were deliberately constructed through government partnership with private investors at moments when private capital was unwilling or unable to flow where the country needed it most.

That same toolkit is available today and can help harness private investment to address national issues that are bipartisan priorities, such as housing affordability, educational access, healthcare, and energy production. They thirst for private capital that is not reaching everywhere our country needs it to go. Government does not need to become the investor of first resort to close that gap. It needs to change the risk and return calculus facing the private investors who already exist.

The Play: Five Tools Government Can Use to Steer Capital

Over the past century, the federal government and states have developed four proven tools for steering investment into national priorities, while a fifth now gaining bipartisan momentum.

The common thread: government does not need to pick winners or own companies to move markets. Done well, these tools absorb risk at the margin and let private capital do what it already does best, in more places where it can also do more good.

Why This Is a Bipartisan Opportunity

This agenda draws support across the political spectrum for structural reasons. Many Republicans, after decades of advocating for unregulated markets, have come to recognize the need to manage markets to reduce the human cost of unmanaged efficiency. Many Democrats, after decades focused on constraining investors from doing harm, now recognize they cannot achieve their priorities without leveraging private investment to finance them. And several of the tools above, such as the SBIC program, LIHTC, and the DOE loan program, are structured to be fee-funded and near-zero-subsidy, which matters in an era of large federal deficits and divided government.

Bipartisan political support is not automatic. Government intervention in capital markets is difficult to design well, corruptible, vulnerable to being read as favoritism or a "bailout," and exploitable by investors looking to capture a subsidy without taking on real risk or redirecting real investment. But the tools above have decades of precedent behind them in Republican and Democratic administrations. This is not a new argument, only a case for applying it with renewed discipline and ambition.

How I Can Help

I wrote Investing in America to shine a light on the incredible people doing this work and the opportunities we have to solve national challenges if we can harness America's vast capital markets to support them. I co-founded Lafayette Square Institute, a policy institute built specifically to bridge government and the capital markets, and have helped advance bipartisan legislation grounded in that work. I ran a national nonprofit community development finance loan fund for 10 years, working in partnership with federal and state agencies and the White House. I bring that same experience to policy organizations who want to develop bipartisan messaging and strategy that advances this agenda, grounded in the historical understanding that these tools have consistently drawn support across the political spectrum.

My book is one grateful immigrant's 250th-birthday gift to the country that has given me and my family so much. This work is an ongoing act of appreciation and opportunity to pay it forward.

—Antony

To get in touch: antony@bugglevine.com

Want to Put This Into Practice?

Talk to Antony Download as PDF